In 1997, as Marvel prepared to relaunch IRON MAN after taking the character back from Jim Lee’s WildStorm Productions, I was asked to submit some logo ideas. I have to say that none of the ones I turned in were particularly inspired. Maybe it was because I liked the one I had done the previous year for WildStorm and didn’t want to compete with it, I don’t know. The first one, above, did at least have the slick appearance of polished metal, a popular logo trick at the time, but the letter forms aren’t terribly interesting. And using this kind of 3D metal logo would have limited Marvel on color choices, too. I could provide a few alternates, like a gold, copper or brass version, but other colors didn’t usually work.
This one, very vertical with pointed endcaps is hard to read, and reminds me of a picket fence. Not surprised they didn’t go for it. After a few more along these lines, word came back to include THE INVINCIBLE and a stylized version of Iron Man’s mask in the next round.
Here’s one I did using the same letterforms as the first version above, but now in line, angled, with a drop shadow, and the mask in the center. Not terrible, but again, not great either. I have to say I never liked the mouth on this version of Iron Man’s mask, though I think it’s based on the original Jack Kirby mask for Doctor Doom. I did a few variations of this. Here’s another:
This one used a circuit design as a background. I’m not sure how it might have worked in color on cover art, but it strikes me as too busy. It did at least introduce another visual element to the logo that related to the character. Electronics had been a part of Iron Man’s armor since the beginning, I think, though the importance and complexity of it continued to grow over the years. But tacking it on in the background, as I did here, wasn’t really a good way to introduce it. I didn’t sell this logo assignment. Someone else, with a much better idea, did.
Richard Starkings of Comicraft came up with the winning design, and he succeeded exactly where I had failed by creating a convincing way to embed that circuit idea into the logo letters themselves. He did it by making a much simpler circuit design than mine, really just the suggestion, but it works well, conveying the idea without being too busy. His use of the face mask is also much better, as it half hides between the two words. More subtle, more effective. Yet the light line around the dark drop shadow and mask highlights the eye and mouth brilliantly. THE INVINCIBLE is small and spread out, giving a nice contrast to the rest. It might have faded into background art, but the solid band behind it removed that problem. I think Comicraft did the entire trade dress here, everything at the top third of the comic. They could have saved some art space by making the yellow and brown color bands less tall, but otherwise it all looks quite good to me, and really kicks Iron Man and his logo into the very late 20th century.
It was JG Roshell, Richard’s partner at Comicraft, who kicked it into the 21st century with this revised version that first appeared in 2002. At first glance this could pass as some kind of circuit board, but a moment later the words IRON MAN are clearly evident, a nice trick! JG has used a lot more square corners on this one, though some round ones remain. A suggestion of serifs has returned to the I, and every letter has a horizontal gap in it, which you would think would take away from the readability, but somehow it doesn’t, at least for me. The most surprising shape is the O. Never in a million years would I have thought that could work as an O, but it does, thanks to the talent of JG. Around everything is a metallic bevel probably done in Photoshop, allowing for a variety of subtle color shadings. THE INVINCIBLE is larger and free floating again, with letterforms that are more standard yet still with attractive quirks, like the horizontal gap in the B. Really well done, and it continues to be used today.
Here it is on the 2005 relaunch of the title. You know you have a strong and popular logo when it survives a relaunch these days.
And right up to 2008, with THE INVINCIBLE replaced by DIRECTOR OF S.H.I.E.L.D. and an Iron Man movie plug. Speaking of which, let’s take a look at that movie logo before we wrap this up.
Movie logos tend to be very conservative these days, usually relying on a few familiar fonts. This one is better than most. Still conservative, but with some flair. I like the letterforms, especially the partial rounds on the O and A. I like the taller I and M, and the highly rendered metal effects (lots of Photoshop work there) give it just the right amount of realism and wear to suggest both actual metal and an iconic, historic name. And they went with the beveled edges, a good choice! Quite well done, though I don’t know by who (or is it whom?).
Hope you’ve enjoyed this brief logo study. I’ll be back with more when I can find the time to do them.
More chapters and other logo studies on my LOGO LINKS page.