
I’m looking forward to the new Superman movie opening tomorrow, I plan to see it this weekend. The first trailer, which included Krypto, sold me. Since the character’s new chest symbol has been a major feature of marketing and posters, I’ve seen it a lot, and I have some thoughts.

Original Superman artist Joe Shuster’s idea was a yellow triangle with a red letter S for Superman. His drawings of it varied a lot, the one shown here has a serif at the top, and it suggests the the more elaborate versions that would follow, mostly by other artists either in his own studio, or hired by National (DC) Comics.

By 1945, the symbol was larger, more shield-shaped, and had many of the elements that would be used for decades, including the wide middle stroke of the S, the large square serif at the top with a small yellow triangular opening, and a thin red border around the edge of the shield, making that shield mostly red with yellow inserts. In this version, the lower end of the S ends in a slightly wider section that’s almost, but not quite, a serif. Different artists tended to draw the chest symbol with their own small variations, but this was the usual look.

By the 1970s, when I started working at DC, this version was being used on marketed products of all kinds, and was considered the official Superman symbol. Artists were encouraged to follow it as closely as they could in the comics, though without such heavy black outlines, which were used here so that it would work at small sizes. Note that the bottom now ends in an oval serif, I’m not sure when that began. It’s an odd choice rather than another square serif as at the top, but it does echo Joe Shuster’s original ideas, and it makes for a unique design. I can’t say who designed it. As part of my job as a DC production artist, I often had to correct Superman chest symbols that strayed too far from this model. George Tuska, the original artist of DC’s “The World’s Greatest Superheroes” newspaper strip was particularly bad at it, I corrected lots of his.

Of course, in the comics, the black outlines always defined the symbol, as they defined everything, but in films and on TV, that didn’t work. My first exposure to Superman was “The Adventures of Superman” that ran on TV from 1952 in black and white, and switched to color for 1954-58. (We didn’t have color TV, so I thought they were all in black and white). I think the costume designers did a good job with red and yellow fabric, it’s not quite like the comics version, but close enough. The central curve of the S isn’t really wide enough, but the square top serif looks good, and the bottom sort of serif is very much like the comics version from 1945. The sides of the symbol are slightly curved, also like the comics version.

The first Superman film starring Christopher Reeve will probably always be my favorite for several reasons. I love the film itself, and it reminds me of my early days at DC, where I met Reeve before the film came out, and did design and production work on the tabloid comic DC put out about the film. The costume designers again did a pretty good job with red and yellow fabric, and the edges of the symbol are straight, though I’m puzzled as to why the top serif doesn’t follow the standard model, and is no longer square. On the other hand, the bottom serif is less oval, perhaps a better match for the top one. The central stroke of the S could again be wider, but in general I thought this worked fine. Later Superman films had other variations and versions of the chest symbol, none of which I liked very much, and there were several TV shows with their own versions too, none of them quite right to my eye, but all getting the idea across.

In 1996, painter Alex Ross produced the four-issue KINGDOM COME series with writer Mark Waid, positing alternate versions of the DC heroes. His Superman had the most radically different take on the chest symbol design seen to that point. As with the film and TV versions, there were no black outlines in Alex’s painted art to define the symbol, it was all done with color. To add contrast and drama, Alex made the inserts black.

This version was probably not done by Alex, but by someone else to use for marketing, but it gives a clear view of the entire thing. Alex retained the straight edges of the shield from the DC standard version, but everything inside is different. The wide angular band across the middle sells the S in a more abstract way, with just enough curves at each end to make it read well. The top band of the S now follows the top of the shield and it continues to follow the corner angle, just barely suggesting the original serif. The bottom of the S is gone except for the slight thickening and curve in the bottom corner. To me, it still reads as an S, but to someone unfamiliar with Superman, it might not. Is there anyone not familiar with Superman, though? By the way, I loved lettering the series.

This brings us back to the version created for the new Superman movie, and prominent in the ads for it. The version seen above is about the same, but perhaps with a thinner outer yellow outline.

This version probably has artistically exaggerated elements to make the poster look good, certainly the outer yellow border seems that way, and the central glow, but the design elements are clear. There’s no doubt that it’s based on Alex Ross’s Kingdom Come version, but there are some differences. The broad diagonal central band and the curves at each end of it are straight from Alex’s version, but the top band of the S is thinner, and it’s matched at lower right by a wider band continuing the S shape down to the bottom corner with no curve. While these bands are only slightly wider than the other red edges, they do read well as an S to me. The outer yellow outline is new, brings us back to the original Joe Shuster yellow triangle, and I think helps sell the S as a symbol. I like it a lot. Well done, costume and poster designers!
